Richard Pryor had this great bit in which he asked a woman who saw him cheating with another woman, “Who are you going to believe? Me or your lying eyes?”
The White House is basically asking us the same question — only it’s not so funny.
Over the weekend President Obama, Secretary Sebelius, White House spokesman Gibbs went to great pains to tell us that a public option was not an essential ingredient in health care reform. Indeed, the president said that we were “fixated” on the public option.
Yesterday and today we are being told that the president has not changed positions. Really? As the Washington Post reminded us today,
President Obama had pushed a nonprofit, government-sponsored insurance plan as an alternative to existing insurance companies, saying that a public program would compete with the industry and help reduce costs.
But this is what Gibbs had to say about the “apparent” shift in the president’s priorities:
White House press secretary Robert Gibbs. . .said Obama has not shifted his position, suggesting that the president’s support for a public option had never been absolute. “The goals are choice and competition. His preference is a public option. If there are other ideas, he’s happy to look at them,” Gibbs said. White House officials repeatedly denied that there was any new positioning on the provision, accusing the media of fabricating developments.
Basically, this is the Pryor technique at work in the White House. Our lying eyes and ears are not to be believed. What we saw and heard over the weekend were mere apparitions.
Anyone doing research on this issue can find dozens of occasions when President Obama proclaimed universal coverage as a core principle of health care reform. And, of course, it is and always has been. That is what this fight is about. There are 47 million people in this country without health insurance and not getting the medical attention they need. We are no more fixated on universal coverage than anti-war advocates are fixated on peace. Universal coverage is the centerpiece of reform. Once upon a time, the president was adamant that it was. Now that the GOP and neo-Dems are pushing their own agenda, he is backing away from that commitment.
We can only hope that eventually the president and his staff start believing their own eyes and ears and take note of the millions of people – including leaders in his own party – who are counting on him to bring us real change, not doublespeak and backtracking.